Skip to main content

Selling Is Taking Longer in Littleton and Highlands Ranch. Should You Rent the Home Instead?

Selling Is Taking Longer in Littleton and Highlands Ranch. Should You Rent the Home Instead?

If your home has sat on the market for months, you are not alone: Colorado home sales fell 19% in October compared with a year ago, and sellers are cutting prices or paying buyers’ costs to get deals done. For some owners, renting the home while they wait is a better move than another price cut. This post covers what is happening, what renting looks like, and what to check first.

Tri Home Life manages rental homes for owners in Littleton, Highlands Ranch and Lone Tree.

Why homes are sitting longer

Buyers are scarce and sellers are holding firm. Denver-area house sales fell 20% in October from a year earlier, and pending contracts were down 19%, according to the Colorado Association of Realtors figures reported by The Colorado Sun. The median price in the Denver area slipped less than 1%, to $619,000.

The price on the sign is not the whole story. Denver County saw 64% of sales close with a seller concession in October, up from 55% two years ago, and about half of those homes also had a price reduction. Sellers are giving up money in quieter ways before a sale closes.

Mortgage rates are a big reason. The 30-year fixed rate was 7.5% in mid-November, compared with 6.4% a year earlier, so the same price now means a higher monthly payment for the buyer.

If your home has been listed 90 days or more and has already had a cut, you are in a large group. The question is what to do next.

What renting instead looks like

Renting turns a house that is costing you money each month into one that covers some or all of its costs while you wait for a better market or better timing.

A property manager handles the parts that make owners hesitate: marketing the home, screening applicants, signing the lease, collecting rent, and coordinating repairs. At Tri Home Life, the owner keeps control of the property and the decision to sell later.

A few practical points:

  • A lease has an end date. A 12-month lease gives you a clear point to list again, or the tenant may buy.
  • Timing matters. Winter leases take planning, and the lease can be set to end before the spring market.
  • You do not have to choose forever. Renting for a season or a year is a way to wait, not a permanent decision.
  • Your listing agent can stay in the picture. Many owners come back to their agent when it is time to sell, and a manager can help line that up.

The numbers to run before you decide

Compare what the home costs you each month empty against what it costs you rented. The figures below are an example with round numbers, not a quote and not a prediction for your home.

Monthly, example onlyEmptyRented
Mortgage, taxes, insurance, HOA, utilities and lawn$4,300$4,300
Rent collected$0$3,300
Management fee (example: 8% of rent)$0$264
Out of pocket each month$4,300$1,264


In this example, six months of renting leaves you about $18,200 better off than six months empty ($3,036 a month times six), before one-time leasing costs and repairs. A further $25,000 price cut would have to bring a buyer faster than the rental does to come out ahead.

To run your own version, you need five numbers: your total monthly cost of owning the home, a realistic rent, the management and leasing fees, the repairs and turnover you should set aside for, and the price you would net if you sold today. A free starting rent estimate is on the Tri Home Life home page, in the center of the page.

What to check before you rent

Renting is not right for every home. Check these first, ideally before you sign a lease:

  1. Your HOA’s rules. Many Highlands Ranch and Littleton communities limit rentals or set a minimum lease length. Read your governing documents, or ask the association in writing.
  2. Your loan. Some mortgages require you to live in the home. Ask your lender how renting affects your loan terms.
  3. Your insurance. A homeowner policy often does not cover a rental. Ask your agent about a landlord policy.
  4. Local rental rules. Cities and counties can have licensing or registration requirements. Confirm the rules where your home is.
  5. Your plan to sell. If you are likely to sell within a year, make sure the lease end date fits that plan.

This is general information, not legal or tax advice. Ask your attorney or tax professional about your own situation.

If you want to run the numbers for your home, you can schedule a call with TJ.

Photo: Aspen Metzger / Unsplash

back